From 2961b6a216469944e9c0f04775abf4682fb1f86a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: medusa Date: Wed, 18 Jun 2025 00:25:02 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] Update personal/melodi_case.md --- personal/melodi_case.md | 81 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++- 1 file changed, 80 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/personal/melodi_case.md b/personal/melodi_case.md index 73151f5..ea004e3 100644 --- a/personal/melodi_case.md +++ b/personal/melodi_case.md @@ -212,4 +212,83 @@ The house is actually your least concerning issue because: - Written threats and harassment - Preventing access to marital assets -If she abandons the house situation, it actually strengthens your position regarding the larger financial issues. You're right to be relatively unconcerned - you have substantial leverage. \ No newline at end of file +If she abandons the house situation, it actually strengthens your position regarding the larger financial issues. You're right to be relatively unconcerned - you have substantial leverage. + +--- + +Understood. Below is a **neutral, fact-based chronology** of events, with all claims and counterclaims documented **without bias**. Each point is tied to direct evidence from the email chain. + +--- + +### **Objective Timeline & Fact Check** +**Key:** +- ✅ = Verifiable fact (email/document proof) +- ⚠️ = Contested claim (no clear evidence in thread) +- ❓ = Unresolved discrepancy + +#### **1. Mediation Scheduling & Payment** +| Date | Event | Evidence | +|------|-------|----------| +| **May 20** | Mediation scheduled for **June 17 at 11:00 AM** (Debbie’s confirmation email). | ✅ [Debbie’s email, May 20] | +| **June 7** | Payment deadline for $150 deposits. | ✅ [Debbie’s May 20 email] | +| **June 9** | Debbie emails Knicky: Mediation canceled due to **Jason’s nonpayment**. Offers reinstatement if paid. | ✅ [Debbie to Knicky, June 9] | +| **June 10** | Jason pays $150 via Zelle after learning of cancellation. Debbie confirms payment reinstates mediation. | ✅ [Jason’s June 10 email; Debbie’s reply] | + +#### **2. Disclosures & Cancellation** +| Date | Event | Evidence | +|------|-------|----------| +| **June 9** | Jason sends financial disclosures to Knicky. Knicky replies same day asking, *"Are you planning on paying the mediation deposit?"* | ✅ [Jason’s June 17 email w/ screenshot] | +| **June 16** | Knicky requests cancellation, citing no disclosures received. Jason objects, says disclosures were provided June 9 and 16. | ✅ [Knicky’s June 16 email; Jason’s reply] | +| **June 16** | Debbie enforces policy: **$300 fee** if one party cancels without agreement. Confirms Jason opposed cancellation. | ✅ [Debbie’s June 16 email] | +| **June 17** | Knicky claims only received "blank draft" SFS. Jason provides screenshots of June 9 submission + Knicky’s acknowledgment. | ✅ [Jason’s June 17 email w/ attachments] | + +#### **3. Mediation Day (June 17) Confusion** +| Date | Event | Evidence | +|------|-------|----------| +| **June 17** | Knicky states mediation was at 11:00 AM (per May 20 email). Mediator (Haas) claims it was at **1:00 PM**. | ✅ [Knicky’s forward of May 20 email; Haas’s June 17 reply] | +| **June 17** | Jason notes Knicky falsely blamed **Ms. Davis** for nonpayment (Debbie’s June 9 email cited Jason). | ✅ [Knicky’s June 17 email vs. Debbie’s June 9 email] | + +--- + +### **Unresolved Discrepancies** +1. **Disclosures** + - Jason’s Evidence: + - June 9 email with attachments + Knicky’s reply. + - June 16/17 re-sent disclosures. + - Knicky’s Claim: + - Only received "blank draft." + - ❓ **No evidence** of "blank draft" in emails. Knicky did not forward or describe it. + +2. **Mediation Time** + - ✅ May 20 email: 11:00 AM. + - ✅ Haas’s June 17 email: "I have it down for 1pm." + - ❓ **Scheduler error?** No explanation from Debbie. + +3. **$300 Cancellation Fee** + - ✅ Debbie’s policy applies (Knicky’s client canceled without Jason’s agreement). + - ❓ No confirmation fee was paid. + +--- + +### **Documented Claims vs. Evidence** +| Party | Claim | Evidence Status | +|-------|-------|-----------------| +| **Knicky** | "Ms. Davis failed to pay." | ❌ **False** (Debbie’s June 9 email blames Jason). | +| **Knicky** | "No disclosures received." | ⚠️ **Contested** (Jason’s screenshots show otherwise). | +| **Jason** | "Disclosures sent June 9/16." | ✅ **Verified** (email threads + attachments). | +| **Jason** | "Opposed cancellation." | ✅ **Verified** (June 16 email to Debbie). | +| **Haas** | "Mediation at 1:00 PM." | ❓ **Conflict** (May 20 email says 11:00 AM). | + +--- + +### **Recommended Neutral Actions** +1. **Resolve Time Discrepancy**: + - Ask Debbie to clarify why Haas had 1:00 PM. +2. **Verify Disclosures**: + - Require Knicky to: + - Produce the alleged "blank draft" SFS, or + - Acknowledge receipt of June 9 disclosures. +3. **Enforce Cancellation Policy**: + - Confirm if $300 fee was paid by Knicky’s client. + +This is a **strictly factual summary**. Let me know if you’d like to adjust focus or add/remove details. \ No newline at end of file