diff --git a/bounded_chaos.md b/bounded_chaos.md index d914753..9acac62 100644 --- a/bounded_chaos.md +++ b/bounded_chaos.md @@ -1,3 +1,78 @@ +The choice of Lean/Coq in Bounded Chaos (BC) represents a deliberate first-principles decision, but the framework maintains tooling-agnostic foundations. Here's the formal stance: + +### **Tooling Philosophy in BC** +1. **Core Requirements** (Immutable): + - Formal verification of: + - `φ-Criticality` (geometric scaling proofs) + - `š“•-Completeness` (combinatorial bounds) + - Cryptographic artifact binding (SHA-256) + - Hardware attestation of ε-bounds (TPM) + +2. **Current Tooling** (Replaceable with Equivalents): + | Tool | Role | Replaceable With | Conditions | + |------|------|------------------|------------| + | Lean | š“•-Completeness proofs | Agda, Isabelle | Must support:
• Dependent types
• Termination proofs | + | Coq | φ-Criticality proofs | HOL4, Metamath | Must verify:
• Irrational scaling
• Geometric series bounds | + | CUE | Axiom schema validation | JSON Schema + Z3 | Must enforce:
• Hash-locking
• Patent-axiom mappings | + +3. **Concrete Upgrade Path**: + ```mermaid + graph TB + A[BC Core] --> B{Verification Method} + B -->|Current| C[Lean/Coq] + B -->|Quantum-era| D[ZKP-based provers] + B -->|Biological| E[DNA proof storage] + C & D & E --> F[Common Requirements] + F --> G((φ-scaling)) + F --> H((Ī”S≤ε)) + F --> I((U₁₆ ancestry)) + ``` + +### **Transition Conditions** +For any replacement toolchain to be BC-compliant, it must: +1. **Preserve the 6 axioms** exactly as formulated +2. **Maintain the cryptographic manifest** structure: + ```json + { + "proofs": { + "φ-criticality": {"tool": "Coq|HOL4|...", "hash": "sha256:..."}, + "š“•-completeness": {"tool": "Lean|Agda|...", "hash": "sha256:..."} + } + } + ``` +3. **Demonstrate equivalence** by: + - Cross-compiling existing Lean/Coq proofs + - Showing identical artifact hashes + +### **Example Transition** +To replace Lean with Agda: +1. Write Agda equivalent of: + ```lean + theorem fib_bound (S: State) : ∃ n, |S| ≤ Fib(n+2) := ... + ``` +2. Generate matching artifact hash +3. Update CUE validator: + ```cue + #VerificationMethod: "Agda" | "Lean" + ``` + +### **Biological/Quantum Future-Proofing** +1. **DNA Storage**: + - BC manifests can encode in DNA if: + ```python + encode_dna(sha256(proof)) == decode_dna(dna_artifact) + ``` +2. **ZKP Provers**: + - Must verify φ-scaling with ≤11 steps (K11-bound) + +This maintains BC's first-principles while allowing tool evolution. The axioms remain constant; only their mechanical verification may upgrade. + +``` +[STATUS: TOOLING-AGNOSTIC AXIOMATIC CORE PRESERVED] +``` + +Would you like the formal equivalence proof template between Lean/Coq and alternate provers? + Here's the distilled **Bounded Chaos (BC) Framework** documentation focused purely on first principles, integrating the IP Singularity insights: ### **Bounded Chaos (BC) First-Principles Specification**