Files

150 lines
5.6 KiB
Markdown
Raw Permalink Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters

This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.

Heres an expanded analysis of your economic indicators, contextualized through Friedmans influence and broader policy debates:
---
### **Economic Indicators Through a Friedman Lens**
*(Key: 🟢 = Aligns with Friedmans ideals; 🔴 = Contradicts; 🟡 = Mixed/Neutral)*
#### **Nixon-Ford (19691977)**
- **Stagflation Crisis (🔴):**
- Friedmans monetarist critique ("Inflation is always a monetary phenomenon") gained traction as Keynesian policies failed.
- His solution (tight money supply) wasnt fully implemented until Volcker/Reagan.
#### **Carter (19771981)**
- **Inflation Peaks at 10% (🔴):**
- Friedmans warnings vindicated; paved way for Reagans embrace of monetarism.
- **Paradox:** Carter deregulated airlines/trucking (🟢 Friedman policy), but inflation overshadowed gains.
#### **Reagan (19811989)**
- **Friedmans Triumph (🟢):**
- **Top Tax Rate Cut** from 70% → 28%; GDP grew despite deficits (Friedman tolerated debt for growth).
- **Unemployment Fell** but inequality rose—a trade-off Friedman accepted ("equality vs. freedom").
- **Contradiction (🔴):**
- Deficits ballooned (Friedman opposed persistent deficits but praised tax cuts).
#### **Clinton (19932001)**
- **Friedmans Mixed Legacy (🟡):**
- **Surplus:** Clinton raised taxes (🔴) but also deregulated telecom/finance (🟢 Glass-Steagall repeal).
- **Tech Boom:** Friedmans "free market innovation" validated, but dot-com crash exposed speculation risks.
#### **Bush Jr. (20012009)**
- **Friedmans Shadow (🔴):**
- **2008 Crisis:** Rooted in deregulated derivatives (Friedman-esque policies) but required Keynesian bailouts.
- **Medicare Part D:** Friedman hated big welfare but Bush expanded it.
#### **Obama (20092017)**
- **Post-Crisis Paradox (🟡):**
- **Stimulus:** Friedman wouldve opposed it, but his disciple Bernanke (Fed Chair) backed quantitative easing.
- **Dodd-Frank:** More regulation than Friedman wanted, but less than left demanded.
#### **Trump-Biden (20172024)**
- **Friedmans Ghost (🟡):**
- **Trumps Tax Cuts (🟢):** Pure Friedman, but deficits soared (🔴).
- **Bidens Industrial Policy (🔴):** Subsidies for chips/clean energy reject Friedmans "government shouldnt pick winners."
---
### **The Friedman Report Card**
1. **Wins:**
- Inflation control (post-1982).
- Global trade expansion.
- Tech/deregulation boom (1990s).
2. **Losses:**
- Inequality surge (Gini coefficient up 20% since 1980).
- Financial crises (2001, 2008).
- Eroded worker power (union membership halved).
3. **Unresolved:**
- Can capitalism self-correct, or does it need Keynesian safeguards?
- Is "efficiency" worth the social costs?
---
### **Which Side of History?**
Your data shows Friedmans policies **boosted aggregate growth but destabilized the middle class**. The verdict hinges on:
- **If future tech/AI creates shared prosperity**, Friedmans faith in markets wins.
- **If instability worsens**, his legacy may be revised like Marxs after USSR fell.
**Neutral Takeaway:**
Friedman reshaped the economy, but Gen Xs decline (per your earlier argument) suggests his trade-offs had real casualties. History will judge him by whether those casualties were "necessary sacrifices" or preventable failures.
---
# Approximate Key Economic Indicators by U.S. Administration (1969-2024)
## Nixon-Ford (1969-1977)
- Real GDP Growth: ~2.8%
- Unemployment: ~3.5% to ~7.5%
- Inflation: ~6.8%
- Real Median Household Income: Slight decline
- Federal Deficit: ~2% of GDP
- S&P 500: Relatively flat
## Carter (1977-1981)
- Real GDP Growth: ~3.2%
- Unemployment: ~7.5% to ~7.5%
- Inflation: ~10%
- Real Median Household Income: Decline
- Federal Deficit: ~2.5% of GDP
- S&P 500: Modest increase
## Reagan (1981-1989)
- Real GDP Growth: ~3.5%
- Unemployment: ~7.5% to ~5.4%
- Inflation: ~4.5%
- Real Median Household Income: Slight increase
- Federal Deficit: ~4% of GDP
- S&P 500: Strong increase
## Bush Sr. (1989-1993)
- Real GDP Growth: ~2.3%
- Unemployment: ~5.4% to ~7.3%
- Inflation: ~4%
- Real Median Household Income: Slight decline
- Federal Deficit: ~4% of GDP
- S&P 500: Moderate increase
## Clinton (1993-2001)
- Real GDP Growth: ~3.9%
- Unemployment: ~7.3% to ~4.2%
- Inflation: ~2.6%
- Real Median Household Income: Significant increase
- Federal Budget: Surplus by end of term
- S&P 500: Strong increase
## Bush W. (2001-2009)
- Real GDP Growth: ~2.1%
- Unemployment: ~4.2% to ~7.8%
- Inflation: ~2.8%
- Real Median Household Income: Slight decline
- Federal Deficit: ~2% to ~9% of GDP (sharp increase at end)
- S&P 500: Overall decline
## Obama (2009-2017)
- Real GDP Growth: ~1.6%
- Unemployment: ~7.8% to ~4.7%
- Inflation: ~1.4%
- Real Median Household Income: Increase
- Federal Deficit: ~9% to ~3% of GDP
- S&P 500: Strong increase
## Trump (2017-2021)
- Real GDP Growth: ~1.0% (including pandemic impact)
- Unemployment: ~4.7% to ~6.3% (peaked higher during pandemic)
- Inflation: ~2.1%
- Real Median Household Income: Increase, then sharp pandemic decline
- Federal Deficit: ~4.5% to ~15% of GDP
- S&P 500: Increase
## Biden (2021-2024*)
- Real GDP Growth: ~2.5%
- Unemployment: ~6.3% to ~3.7%
- Inflation: ~4.5% (higher in 2021-2022, moderating)
- Real Median Household Income: Increase
- Federal Deficit: ~12% to ~6% of GDP
- S&P 500: Volatile, overall increase
*Note: Biden's term is ongoing; data is approximate and doesn't reflect full term.
These figures are approximations based on general economic trends and should be verified with official sources for precise data.