medusa/the_information_nexus
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
8cdd607974c46119ecb454e9f4d37da8f5907285
the_information_nexus/financial_docs/economy.md

5.6 KiB
Raw Blame History

Here’s an expanded analysis of your economic indicators, contextualized through Friedman’s influence and broader policy debates:

Economic Indicators Through a Friedman Lens

(Key: 🟢 = Aligns with Friedman’s ideals; 🔴 = Contradicts; 🟡 = Mixed/Neutral)

Nixon-Ford (1969–1977)

  • Stagflation Crisis (🔴):
    • Friedman’s monetarist critique ("Inflation is always a monetary phenomenon") gained traction as Keynesian policies failed.
    • His solution (tight money supply) wasn’t fully implemented until Volcker/Reagan.

Carter (1977–1981)

  • Inflation Peaks at 10% (🔴):
    • Friedman’s warnings vindicated; paved way for Reagan’s embrace of monetarism.
    • Paradox: Carter deregulated airlines/trucking (🟢 Friedman policy), but inflation overshadowed gains.

Reagan (1981–1989)

  • Friedman’s Triumph (🟢):
    • Top Tax Rate Cut from 70% → 28%; GDP grew despite deficits (Friedman tolerated debt for growth).
    • Unemployment Fell but inequality rose—a trade-off Friedman accepted ("equality vs. freedom").
  • Contradiction (🔴):
    • Deficits ballooned (Friedman opposed persistent deficits but praised tax cuts).

Clinton (1993–2001)

  • Friedman’s Mixed Legacy (🟡):
    • Surplus: Clinton raised taxes (🔴) but also deregulated telecom/finance (🟢 Glass-Steagall repeal).
    • Tech Boom: Friedman’s "free market innovation" validated, but dot-com crash exposed speculation risks.

Bush Jr. (2001–2009)

  • Friedman’s Shadow (🔴):
    • 2008 Crisis: Rooted in deregulated derivatives (Friedman-esque policies) but required Keynesian bailouts.
    • Medicare Part D: Friedman hated big welfare but Bush expanded it.

Obama (2009–2017)

  • Post-Crisis Paradox (🟡):
    • Stimulus: Friedman would’ve opposed it, but his disciple Bernanke (Fed Chair) backed quantitative easing.
    • Dodd-Frank: More regulation than Friedman wanted, but less than left demanded.

Trump-Biden (2017–2024)

  • Friedman’s Ghost (🟡):
    • Trump’s Tax Cuts (🟢): Pure Friedman, but deficits soared (🔴).
    • Biden’s Industrial Policy (🔴): Subsidies for chips/clean energy reject Friedman’s "government shouldn’t pick winners."

The Friedman Report Card

  1. Wins:

    • Inflation control (post-1982).
    • Global trade expansion.
    • Tech/deregulation boom (1990s).

  2. Losses:

    • Inequality surge (Gini coefficient up 20% since 1980).
    • Financial crises (2001, 2008).
    • Eroded worker power (union membership halved).

  3. Unresolved:

    • Can capitalism self-correct, or does it need Keynesian safeguards?
    • Is "efficiency" worth the social costs?

Which Side of History?

Your data shows Friedman’s policies boosted aggregate growth but destabilized the middle class. The verdict hinges on:

  • If future tech/AI creates shared prosperity, Friedman’s faith in markets wins.
  • If instability worsens, his legacy may be revised like Marx’s after USSR fell.

Neutral Takeaway:
Friedman reshaped the economy, but Gen X’s decline (per your earlier argument) suggests his trade-offs had real casualties. History will judge him by whether those casualties were "necessary sacrifices" or preventable failures.

Approximate Key Economic Indicators by U.S. Administration (1969-2024)

Nixon-Ford (1969-1977)

  • Real GDP Growth: ~2.8%
  • Unemployment: ~3.5% to ~7.5%
  • Inflation: ~6.8%
  • Real Median Household Income: Slight decline
  • Federal Deficit: ~2% of GDP
  • S&P 500: Relatively flat

Carter (1977-1981)

  • Real GDP Growth: ~3.2%
  • Unemployment: ~7.5% to ~7.5%
  • Inflation: ~10%
  • Real Median Household Income: Decline
  • Federal Deficit: ~2.5% of GDP
  • S&P 500: Modest increase

Reagan (1981-1989)

  • Real GDP Growth: ~3.5%
  • Unemployment: ~7.5% to ~5.4%
  • Inflation: ~4.5%
  • Real Median Household Income: Slight increase
  • Federal Deficit: ~4% of GDP
  • S&P 500: Strong increase

Bush Sr. (1989-1993)

  • Real GDP Growth: ~2.3%
  • Unemployment: ~5.4% to ~7.3%
  • Inflation: ~4%
  • Real Median Household Income: Slight decline
  • Federal Deficit: ~4% of GDP
  • S&P 500: Moderate increase

Clinton (1993-2001)

  • Real GDP Growth: ~3.9%
  • Unemployment: ~7.3% to ~4.2%
  • Inflation: ~2.6%
  • Real Median Household Income: Significant increase
  • Federal Budget: Surplus by end of term
  • S&P 500: Strong increase

Bush W. (2001-2009)

  • Real GDP Growth: ~2.1%
  • Unemployment: ~4.2% to ~7.8%
  • Inflation: ~2.8%
  • Real Median Household Income: Slight decline
  • Federal Deficit: ~2% to ~9% of GDP (sharp increase at end)
  • S&P 500: Overall decline

Obama (2009-2017)

  • Real GDP Growth: ~1.6%
  • Unemployment: ~7.8% to ~4.7%
  • Inflation: ~1.4%
  • Real Median Household Income: Increase
  • Federal Deficit: ~9% to ~3% of GDP
  • S&P 500: Strong increase

Trump (2017-2021)

  • Real GDP Growth: ~1.0% (including pandemic impact)
  • Unemployment: ~4.7% to ~6.3% (peaked higher during pandemic)
  • Inflation: ~2.1%
  • Real Median Household Income: Increase, then sharp pandemic decline
  • Federal Deficit: ~4.5% to ~15% of GDP
  • S&P 500: Increase

Biden (2021-2024*)

  • Real GDP Growth: ~2.5%
  • Unemployment: ~6.3% to ~3.7%
  • Inflation: ~4.5% (higher in 2021-2022, moderating)
  • Real Median Household Income: Increase
  • Federal Deficit: ~12% to ~6% of GDP
  • S&P 500: Volatile, overall increase

*Note: Biden's term is ongoing; data is approximate and doesn't reflect full term.

These figures are approximations based on general economic trends and should be verified with official sources for precise data.